HE SAID YES!

Turns out he was just completely clueless about the whole thing and thought that I was just giving him a CD/storing one in his locker until I could get it for something. Literally, when he FINALLY texted me back, he said "Yeah, do you need it back?" I had to spell it out for him pretty hard core! It's kinda hilarious, though! All's well that ends well, I guess!